Hey, there! Log in / Register

Warmer temps made fish suffocate in Jamaica Pond

The Jamaica Plain Gazette reports.

Neighborhoods: 
Free tagging: 


Ad:


Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!

Comments

Do you parrot every piece of nonsence or propagandist you have been feed without question? It has been colder than normal this year.

up
Voting closed 0

Read the article silly! The recent large temperature swings cold/hot/cold in conjunction with the state restocking the lake overcrowded the number of fish to available oxygen in water experiencing large temperature swings. This has nothing to do with climate, it is a regular natural occurrence with the wild temperature swings of early spring weather at bodies of water overstocked with fish.

up
Voting closed 0

You obviously have no short-term memory left, so you'll just have to take my word that the Gazette article (which I linked to, but which you might have trouble retaining) was about those two days a few days ago when the temperature got near 80, and that that caused problems in a pond newly stocked with fish.

up
Voting closed 0

But it ended the same way. The article says that this is a common, albeit strange, occurrence.

To be fair to the crazy commenter, the day with the 50 degree high must of had him forgetting that we ever had warm weather.

up
Voting closed 0

For your next post, please do let us know how a dead Orange line train is evidence of a Benghazi coverup.

up
Voting closed 0

What I don't get is why the fish didn't attempt to swim downstream to where the is more oxygen in the Muddy River. Is there some sort of barrier which keeps them from migrating from the pond?

up
Voting closed 0

Turnover in a pond like that can happen quickly. There's a layer of anoxic cold water trapped in the depths of the lake, where bacteria have been busily consuming dead phytoplankton and using up the oxygen all winter. Spring comes, the temperature difference between the warm top layer and cold deep layer makes the layers unstable. Wind action turns the lake over, suddenly oxygen levels drop in the upper warm layer. These recently stocked fish have no chance to adapt or move. It does happen fairly often.

up
Voting closed 0

than keeping watersheds in a condition that would support robust fish populations.

Hatchery fish are like factory chickens and are dumped dazed into streams alien to their dna.

Fishing snobs consider a brook trout that was actually born in the stream it was hooked in to be a kind of grail.

Art Flick was a fly fishing stream ecologist who came up with a more sensible approach.

He encouraged people to plant lots of willows along stream beds as they stabilize the channel and makes it cut deeper. And they also shade the stream for cooler temps.

http://www.catskillsearch.com/site/2007/06/27/art-flick-memorial/

up
Voting closed 0

Hatchery fish are like factory chickens and are dumped dazed into streams alien to their dna.

Perch, like the ones stocked in Jamaica Pond, are native to ponds and lakes of New England. Plus after years of stocking, there's nothing alien about their DNA in that water.

I'm not saying that stocking waterways is the best approach, but the fish they are stocking aren't from out of town...or this world. They're the same fish that would live there anyways, but in greater numbers to allow sustained fishing.

up
Voting closed 0

Oddly the Commonwealth doesn't reference white perch in its hatchery system.

http://www.mass.gov/eea/agencies/dfg/dfw/about-masswildlife/state-fish-h...

However, there is a hatchery in West Virginia that sources them.

http://www.zettsfishhatchery.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderfiles/Com...

And Maine stocks em too.

Some background from a pdf they have. It's a management plan

http://www.maine.gov/ifw/fishing/species/management_plans/whiteperch.pdf

White perch are closely related to striped bass, which live principally in salt or brackish water. Although both species are capable of living in salt water, they both spawn in fresh water.

The white perch spawns mainly in the spring at water temperatures around 59-60 degrees F.
Spawning takes place in shallow water over almost any bottom type. The total number of eggs
per female varies from 20,000 to 300,000 depending on the size of the fish. A 6-inch long perch
would have approximately 22,000 eggs. The eggs hatch in 4-5 days at 59-60 degrees F. The
average life span is 5-7 years. Perch can survive and often thrive in most Maine lakes and ponds
of approximately 50 acres or more in size and about 25 feet or more in depth if the deeper water
is not depleted of oxygen during the winter months.

Perch are considered to be a warmwater fish because they seek out and grow better in warmer water. White perch do better in waters that reach a temperature of 75 degrees F. or higher in the summer months. Perch eat most small creatures that other fish eat, and large perch will eat most small fish including their own species.

Where conditions are favorable, white perch form very large populations that occasionally
dominate the waters they inhabit. Their reproductive potential is so great that only major
mortalities induced by unfavorable weather at spawning time can cause failures in certain year
classes. Loss of year classes, however, causes few problems in the management of white perch.

Usually the problem is one of too many small perch. Even small, slow-growing perch can mature
and spawn successfully thus preserving a population. Fishermen prefer larger perch for food and
sport and are likely to complain when the perch are all small.

Zetts will sell you a truckload.

Note the last paragraph about mortality causes..unfavorable weather at spawning time.

I'm mainly parroting the argument I've heard from fishing purists and should have made the DNA role more specific. Anadromous fish in the wild will have facets of their birth stream encoded in their DNA. It's how they know where to swim upstream.

But, in the case of, say, trout, if you dump a brown trout born in a hatchery in Montague in a tributary of the Parker River in Newbury, it'll have to wing it on spawning locations.

Hatchery fish of all species are said to be less hardy.

There was a round of arguments several years ago about the hazards of Atlantic Salmon fish farming and their escape from pens

Here's a paper from a marine science journal on that situation.

http://icesjms.oxfordjournals.org/content/63/7/1159.full

up
Voting closed 0

I think you might be confusing white perch (Morone americana) with yellow perch (Perca flavescens).

up
Voting closed 0

You're right.

up
Voting closed 0

The poor fish. Such a waste, they would have made a nice meal.

up
Voting closed 0