Another Boston firefighter gone bad (allegedly, of course)

On the same day the bodybuilding firefighter tries to get his job back comes this news:

A Boston deputy fire chief is accused of posing as a state trooper and raping a woman at gunpoint last month, Boston Fire Department officials said.

|

So is he on paid leave, or

By NotWhitey | Tue, 08/19/2008 - 3:37pm

So is he on paid leave, or not on paid leave?

only an accusation - This can happen to you, guys!

By deselby | Tue, 08/19/2008 - 4:26pm

This looks like a shaky case, you should have held off before posting:

The Globe has reported more details:

boston.com.../deputy_fire_chi.html

Money quote:

In early July, after having been detained as a "common night walker," a woman reported to police that she had been sexually assaulted by a highway patrol officer two weeks earlier, Middleton said.

Years ago, I was appointed as a public defender for a man arrested and hauled into court on a charge of rape.

He worked at John Hancock and was walking out of the Au Bon Pain at Boylston and Berkeley when a woman accompanied by a police officer pointed at him and "That's him, that's the man who raped me." The man was arrested on the street, booked and brought to court that afternoon, where I met him.

The police report for the rape was from about 6 months before that. The woman reported that a man had broken into her apartment and raped her a day before. There were significant differences between the description of the rapist in the police report and the man who was arrested that day. There was no DNA.

The man had no record. He was released on recognizance because of the different descriptions. If the descriptions were closer, he might have been held without bail. The case was eventually dismissed.

Fortunately, he was not a firefighter and it was before the internet, so his arrest was not reported and his name not associated with rape.

Welcome New Commentator

By SwirlyGrrl | Tue, 08/19/2008 - 5:23pm

I don't suppose the subject matter had much to do with your recent arrival, did it?

Welcome ad hominem

By Brett | Tue, 08/19/2008 - 9:25pm

How new a user they are is irrelevant to the strength of their argument.

Try googling some of the phrases here ...

By SwirlyGrrl | Wed, 08/20/2008 - 9:27am

It doesn't take much.

Does the phrase "urban legend" mean anything to you?

So he's making it all up?

By Dan Farnkoff | Wed, 08/20/2008 - 9:34am

Swirly girl just called you a liar, man. Are you?

used to be able to post anonymously

By deselby | Tue, 08/19/2008 - 9:31pm

No, I used to be able to post anonymously, so I had to register.

I just don't like people being smeared with shaky allegations.

Hmmm, I didn't mention the Duke case, remember that?

I also don't like the snarky glee that goes with allegations against firefighters, who are 99% good.

Do you have anything substantive to say on the subject?

The new guy (hey, I use to

By dmcboston | Wed, 08/20/2008 - 10:09am

The new guy (hey, I use to post here before login) is right. Her story is, ahhh, interesting. Maybe she's just trying to convince the boyfr---um, fiance, that she isn't a hooker. Poor judgmen on Pearson's part, but last I looked, we simply don't have 'highway patrol'. Show me a gun or uniform. Anything beside her word.

I'm calling shenanigans. He's a john, probably, but that's it, in my opinion.
Oh, I'm outta state, on dialup. Gawd...

Explain

By SwirlyGrrl | Wed, 08/20/2008 - 10:37am

How does her being accused of prostitution in the past mean that she was not raped? (that's as a question for deselby, above, as much as anybody else).

It is also possible that if a rape occurred, he told her that he was a "highway patrolman" ... I don't think it matters much who she thought he was ... if there was force, guns, badges involved then she may not have been in any position to question.

a matter of diversion

By deselby | Wed, 08/20/2008 - 1:44pm

Prostitutes can and do get raped, but it is significant that she did not report the rape until she was arrested, two weeks after the alleged rape.

This is sometimes a way of changing the subject, as it converts the arrested woman into a victim who is now entitled to treatment, etc.

Also, in response to other commenters above, there is no indication that the firefighter was a "john."

The alleged victim, along with her "boyfriend," is having a conversation with a police officer on the street. What was the conversation about? Was it a friendly conversation?

Then the alleged victim point's out the firefighter's car (while he is driving by), and says "That's the man who raped me."

It could have been away of deflecting police inquiries and changing the subject.

Just saying.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.