What with this whole Townie/Yuppie thing in Somerville?
O.K. so I'm moving to somerville (davis area) from brighton and I'm totally psyched because I think brighton is really lame and somerville seems so much cooler. I am also looking for a much better quality of life without having to move to the burbs' and still be very close to boston. I was drawn to it because it seemed much different in that it was artsy, diverse, laid-back, and seemed like there are real people there v.s. brighton which is filled with a lot of the same types of people-annoying preppy college kids, and sports obsessed meathead jocks. Not to mention all the trust fund drones who have no idea what life is about.
But all i keep hearing is this Yuppie v.s. Townie thing going on in somerville. The Townies are moving out the Yuppies are moving in bla bla bla. So basically that means if you are moving into somerville you are a Yuppie? Well I am far from a Yuppie and I'm sure as hell not a Townie! I grew up in the city. (not around here)
I don't get it where I come from you are either from the city (or suburb) or from out in the "sticks".
Townies were people from small towns in the "sticks" that were small-minded, ignorant simple people that didn't live in the city and were scared of city people and usually didn't like them. They weren't exposed to much except for there own local stuff that they knew. They often were white-trashy and and bigots.
Yuppies were basically preppy snooty white people with money who thought they were better than everyone and wore a lot of khaki dockers and collared shirts. They usually lived in the suburbs.
So why does it seem that you are either a Yuppie or a Townie if you're in somerville? I despise both and I am definitely not either. So what does that make me? Last time I checked somerville is a city right?
Please hhhhhelp!!! Those who are from or know somerville shed some light on this for me!!



livejournal is THATAWAY
*points*
what??
what are you talking about??
LiveJournal
He means this: http://davis_square.livejournal.com
and to a lesser extent: http://SomervilleMass.livejournal.com
yeah but
thanks but I feel like I would get a broader base on this site but I will post there to!
Livejournal
I assume ze meant that your emotive clueless post would be more appropriate on to post on livejournal, as this site tends to be more for general-interest posting, rather than personal TMI sort of posts.
But I'm just speculating.
This site has a moderator
This site has a moderator who chooses what to accelerate to the to front page. It is also on track to hit close to 100 comments, the previous person was obviously wrong. It may have started off as a specific case but the community has expanded the discussion to a topic of regional interest.
Did it get accelerated to the front page?
I only saw it on the "blogs" page. And yeah, the discussion is certainly interesting.
http://1smootshort.blogspot.com
yes
Exactly people seem very interested in this topic and have a lot to say. It obviously does not just affect somerville or myslef. Almost 100 comments? Cool not bad for my first blog post ever lol!
input on this topic
Apparently many people have input and are interested in this topic here my friend.
I grew up in Somerville and
I grew up in Somerville and lived there until 3 years ago when my wife and I bought a house in Roslindale. I do not know where you are hearing this Yuppie vs Townie thing,those days are long gone. There were issues 15 or so years ago when Somerville went from Slumerville to an atractive place to live. Families who had been living in Somerville for generations were being priced out by the influx of "Yuppies" (the actual term for them in Somerville was Barneys). Somerville was and still is a working class community that has gotten past it's "No Barneys in Somerville stage" (there were T-shirts made with that saying.
You are moving to God's Country my friend. It is the greatest place in the world to live (I left because I got priced out, but this is america). I never understood how there are 6 billion people on the planet and they do not all want to live in the Ville.
Thanks! Sounds good to me.
Thanks! Sounds good to me. As long as by God's Country you don't mean a place filled with bible belting religious nuts! lol
Religious Nuts...
..are everywhere !! My friends uncle used to drive his station wagon covered with scripture all over the city. I am looking for a pic on the web, but have come up empty handed.
Townie is a State of Mind- Yuppies just suck
Outsider from Brighton,
The phrase Townie locally comes from the Townie/Barney dicotomy. The phrase Barney refers to Harvard Types- Yalies made it up (if you've seen the Family Guy episode where they kidnap the pope, there is a good Barney joke there.) Townies were the folks from Cambridge and Somerville who were not university types. Since Yuppies are typically college educated (though they don't know shit), they get the Barney tag. Townie expanded in the area to include anyone "from [wherever]"
I jotted some quick notes on the differences. First is a sense of place. Yuppies will go on about where their new home is like- usually some place in New York, Austin, San Francisco, and the like. For townies, the area just is- Somerville is Somerville, where I am. Second is the sense of time. Yuppies will live in a place until... until they have kids, until their kids are ready for school, until a trendier place comes along. Townies have the intent of staying; though they may not go cradle to grave, if they move, they'll miss the place.
So, as a Roslindale townie, where do I put Erik W? Well, he's a yuppie scum who should leave Roslindale and go back to his beloved Somerville. All kidding aside, this is an issue for you as you leave Brighton. Erik W is not a Roslindale townie (nor is Adam, I think), but he could obtain Roslindale towniedom. It takes time. Townies enjoy their sense of place and understand the importance of time. If you truly come to love a place, and treat it as your home (that's Heimat, not Haus), you could leave the limbo of not townie/definitely not yuppie and become a townie (or leave, but that would give you belated yuppiehood.)
but I love it here!
First time I have been called Yuppie scum, a badge I will wear with honor as I walk around the Sq. (my wife, a JP townie tells me it is the Sq,not the Village)
Square? You're a young'un!
It's a fad of the boomer/post-WW2 crowd to call it Rozzie "Square". For generations before that, it was Rosindale Village, or just "the village".
And back around the civil war, it was "South Street Crossing" - and you still see refs to that in city docs from time to time.
tick tock tick tock
I pride myself on the fact
I pride myself on the fact that I have lived in different places and experienced different types of people and places. You make it sound like a bad thing or a problem. That is what expands your mind, builds your perspective, and broadens your horizons. That is what this great country is about. We have the freedom to go wherever we want and expand our minds, This isn't North Korea. That is some thing a college education alone can't give you (which I happen to have) even or even an ivy league one. You learn so much more in real life experiences which you can only get from living in different areas and hanging with different people. that is where true wisdom comes from and makes you a better person- real world street experience. Or as some call it the school of hard knocks. not just going to school, reading books, and blogs. But it helps. I could never understand why someone could live in the exact same place their whole life without experiencing different places and people. Think about it- If you lived in the same place among the same people your whole life you would end up with a very narrow view of the world like yourself. Which is obvious in you.
Just because I am new to somerville doesn't make me a yuppy, I am bringing in a fresh perspective
to the place and that is a positive aspect. Maybe I'll learn to love it and call it my home. Who know's? But that wont make me a townie. Either way it will add to my perspective and experience in life and you can continue to go to your local townie pub and hate on outsiders.
Yuppie/Townie is more complex
Brighton-soon to be Somerville guy,
It's not necessarily either/or. Think of it as a scale- 1=yuppie, 10=townie. I'm a 7 or 8. Sure, I was born in Rozzie and lived there just about my whole life, but I didn't go to CM or Latin for high school. The reality is that there are Yuppies who are not truly scum and Townies who have a world view beyond their zip code, but to boil it down to basics- Yuppies look beyond their location (its just another stop) while Townies hide behind it. I don't think you need to choose a side, but those are the fault lines in very, very broad strokes.
Erik- as long as you call it the Square, I will retract any references to the y word towards you. Have a few meals at the Pleasant and they'll be asking you about the Rialto.
Vicki..
Cuts my hair at Rialto.
I hit Vicki's car once
I was parking on Washington to walk over to Rialto for a haircut, of all things. Fortunately, no real damage done that we could tell - thank goodness for bumpers.
I'm guessing...
...that ultimately achieving townie-dom means going to lots of wakes and/or funerals (relatives of neighbors, people one goes to church with, etc.)
Actually yeah pretty much.
Actually yeah pretty much. This is also the time when you get to see all the people who left the area years ago for the suburbs. When you spend time with local populations you would be amazed at how many people who live in the burbs talk about the old town/city. In many areas I swear the local paper is aimed more at these people then at the local residents.
Mostly Catholic townies, I think
Yeah, the funeral thing is so true. It seems to be a Catholic townie thing to go to wakes/funerals of people you barely know. Non-townie Catholics don't tend to do this, and it's super-uncommon in circles that aren't Catholic OR townie.
I've had several coworkers who've been Catholic townies and assumed that it's the norm for all funerals to involve a church packed with people they barely know. For myself and many of my friends, it would be really weird to have people present who didn't know the deceased (with a few exceptions of someone who is really close to a mourner). There've been occasions where a coworker has inquired about attending a funeral for another coworker's relative, and I've politely pulled aside the coworker and mentioned that I think it might be a little weird for them to go, since the church-packing-thing isn't really done in our coworker's tradition. The townie coworkers usually thank me later when they do the standard townie-sympathy-expressing-thing of asking how many people were at the church, and the bereaved coworker says there were 30 or 40 people there, or it was a private service with a dozen or so relatives (and often that it wasn't in a church).
(I realize that some of that might sound a bit belittling, so it's not at all meant that way -- we all have things we don't know about other people's cultures and tend to assume that people do things the way we do. It could have just as easily been a non-townie making an ass out of themselves by asking a townie why the hell they were going to a funeral of someone they didn't know, not knowing that this is normal/expected practice in townie culture.)
http://1smootshort.blogspot.com
I find that people will let
I find that people will let you know what their wishes are. If they post it in the local paper, online, and in the Globe then yeah they want the packed church. The kids will post on their myspace/facebook/aim with RIP whoever it is and everyone will be talking about it. On the other hand if they do not want the effect they will be very quiet about it. I had a relative die a while back and some of the causes and aftermath were a little hard to handle. My family essentially put a lid of the wake/funeral without much work. None of my co workers or friends showed up which I was relieved about. They all showed compassion and sent cards after but knew I could not handle them being there and being forced to stand in a mile long receiving line. I am rather used to hundred+ person funeral.
It is a very Catholic thing, it stems from being working class/industrial laborers and recent immigrants. People depended on each other. Old time Catholics are also the self flogging type and what better place to do that then a funeral?
No, you're totally right
That seems to be the case with people who are of the church-packing demographic; I've noticed that families will post it everywhere for some relatives but keep it closer to the family during a loss where they need their space. But people who aren't familiar with that sort of practice will post the funeral information in the paper without it even crossing their mind that people several degrees removed might show up.
http://1smootshort.blogspot.com
No, I am not a townie, even if I do call it Rozzie Square
My daughter, however, is a Rozzie rat, even if she now insists she was not actually born in Roslindale (yeah, yeah, kid, for the purposes of ratdom, Brigham and Women's counts).
Not sure we can help
If by now you don't know what "townie" means in a Boston context, then I'm afraid there's not much we can do.
If you are not familiar with
If you are not familiar with what a townie is, you are surely a yuppie.
I think the Yuppie/Townie thing started off with the yuppies making the difference known, but over time it has become the townie who is making the difference known more. Many yuppies are not even aware they are walking into it anymore, and since the yuppies come and go more frequently may not have the time to figure it out until they become some sort of weird yuppie/townie hyrbid that isnt from these parts but has been here for 20 years.
Townie/Yuppie
Are you a townie?
I know what a townie is from what i have experienced.- check my definition in my original post. What is your definition?
I am definitely not a yuppie unless the definition has drastically change or means some thing different around here. (Check my definition in my original post)
So are you saying that you must be either one or the other or a combination?
Are you saying that a townie is simply form the area and a yuppie is just from somewhere else?
As swirlygirl stated (from
As swirlygirl stated (from what Ive seen from her she is one of those hyrbrids I spoke of in a close by burb to Somerville) Somerville has some of its own terms but they boil down to the same meaning. Every community in the Boston area has their own variations.
Around here townies are the people who lived here before yuppies are those that move in after. In the most simplistic sense townies are auto mechanics, and fast food workers and yuppies are college people and those with money. Those are the main stereotypes but of course both universes are wide and expansive.
The yuppie side of the fence is the first one to state that the argument is over, but that is not the case if you talk to the townie side. In Charlestown there are even sports teams called the Townies, no joke.
Where things get complicated is when you have people like yourself who obviously come from other places to Boston to work and go to school. You do not have allot of money, and in many cases make less then some of the local townies but your still a yuppie. You love the used stores and cheap local food you say? Ah even worse, you see the townies show their because they need to, not because they want to.
It is also complicated for people like me who grew up in the area (not Somerville mind you) but also hold a college education and make more money then the average townie. I am a hybrid going in the opposite direction of Swirlygirl and most likely will end up in someone elses community and at which point I will become a yuppie.
Like any large city
Ok lets not forget like any large city in America like Boston, people come from all over to work and play. They want to be in the city for the excitement, to meet new people, for opportunities you don't get if you lived in some podunk small town. People that live in small towns are usually from there because who would to move to some small town? The people that have been living in that small town are called "Townies" thats where the word originated from. Like swirly girl stated- how could you even have a "townie" in a city. It just doesn't make sense. Most cities are a combination of people from different places to create the dynamic effect of a city. They can't afford to ive right in the city so they live really close to the city with good access to the city (eg: cambridge, somerville) So does that mean that all these people are yuppies just because they are not originally from there? I think you are confusing yuppy with transplant. A transplant does not necessarily make a person a yuppy. that would be an ignorant statement.
I have a college education, but I don't have a ton of money and I don;t work at a fast food place. I am a middle class american which I believe is by far the largest group in America. So that neither makes me a yuppy or a townie. It's just not that cut and dry as you might think.
Overcomplication
I think you are making too much of this. The townie/yuppie thing isn't really a big deal now adays its just people poking fun at eachother. At the most basic level a townie is someone who is "from" here. A Yuppie is someone who isn't. That's about it. Its tough to change groups and some might say impossible. As for Sommerville being a City, and the whole metropolitan thing, look at it this way. When my wife was working for the City of Somerville she once asked a co-worker for directions to South Station from the office (she's not from the area) to which he responded "are you talking about South Station in Boston? How the hell should I know." She also knew people who lived in Sommerville who had not only never been to Boston, but had never been to West Sommerville because they lived in East Sommerville ("why the hell would I go over there"). They were, no question, "from" Somerville and righfully proud of it. As far as they were concerned I was "from" Boston, because that's where I grew up. My poor wife (who made great friends while working at the City depite not being "from" the Ville), is from NY but they were nice and just said she was from the country.
wow
Wow this is the kind of stuff that blows my mind about this area. South Station is only the largest transportation hub in the area! and what it's only like a few miles from somerville? I could even tell you how to get there and I'm not even from here! I just don't get how people can be so closed off and oblivious here. The deep segregation and the way people treat outsiders here just appalls me. It is definitely one of greater boston's major downfalls and shocking for a place that prides itself on being '"the cradle of liberty" and one of the nation's most progressive cities when people live here like its the the early 20th century or something.
Expressing how apalled you are by Boston culture...
...is a great way to endear yourself to the locals.
Bostonians do not feel enriched and enlightened by the dubious fresh perspectives and insights of outsiders.
not what I said- one aspect of
I wasn't speaking about boston culture as a whole I was speaking about one aspect of the culture. Every city has its problems. Oh I'm sorry am I not allowed to have an opinion if I'm bringing to light a negative aspect on the area. Unless you are a fan of segregation you would be appalled to. But maybe you are one of those self-righteous xenophobes. Or maybe you are a townie and you hate yuppys. I don't know but yeah I your damn right I am expressing my opinion and looking for answers and insight. Something you are obviously incapable of. No I am not trying to endear myself to the locals that is not what I'm trying to do here. I wouldn't speak for all bostonians if i were you and make generalizations like that. There are a ton of outsiders in this area and thankful for us that's what makes boston a better and more diverse place to be and I'm not talking just about college kids.
You sound effectively new to the area
Look back at the message to which I was responding.
Imagine the stereotypical obnoxious tourist who barges into a town and starts shooting their mouth off, criticizing things that the locals already know, and saying how shocking and appalling it is, and how oblivious some of the locals are.
I've done that myself, and I've been advised not to let the door hit my butt on the way out.
some people
I noticed I wrote "people" I meant "some people" I didn't mean to generalize all people in Boston. I have met some people that are not like that.
Set membership
I'm not ShadyMilkMan, but I can confirm that you must be either one or the other, or a combination, or neither.
Stereotypes in Brief
Stereotype "townies" are people who live in a large city but act like and think like they live in a small town. It always shocks the heck out of me when I meet a real live extreme one, having actually lived in isolated small communities where people don't have access to the kinds of things they do in major connurbations. It has been 20 years or more since I met somebody living in Somerville who acted like that - I think they all moved to Mefuh a while ago so they could continue to ignore the outside world.
A yuppie is anybody who moved in anytime after they were born. It doesn't matter that you aren't a young professional - it just means that you didn't grow up in a 2 square block radius of where you are living now. There are some extreme pockets of the NE that work like that - sad, but true. In Somerville, it isn't yuppies, but Barnies anyway.
Townies supposedly hate yuppies/barnies for invading their neighborhoods and supposedly pricing them out and destroying their way of life. In reality, most of the residential real estate that changed hands was owner-occupied. Somebody in their extended family sold their multi-generational family house to the newcomers and made a handsome profit on it. (heard on the bus in the mid-80s:"f'n barnies this that etc. ... oh, and how's yer ma doing with her new house in florida?")
The house sales often benefited everybody - money for suburban homes, retirement, college, etc. If you look at the tile project, it is surprising how many of the former Somerville residents will 1) talk about "yuppies" in neutral terms and 2) list places like Andover as their current address.
That evile mass transit line that "nobody wanted" (supposedly) usually gets the blame for all the yuppies moving in (although the fear at the time was that it was going to cause Roxbury to invade and rob everybody, but oh well), rather than the extended family selling out and a slew of socioeconomic and generational trends that were regional and national in scope.
No offense ...
Swirly girl, but your use of the correct plural of Barney (Barnies) lables you, in this somervillians opinion,as in fact a Barney.
I agree with most of your assesment of the situation. The influx of Barneys has made the city a better place for the most part. I would disagree that people supposedly got priced out. I am one of those who got priced out. The city was too expensive for my wife and I to buy what we wanted ( a house and not a condo in a multi family home). My family lived in one of those multi families and rented,never owned our home,and when that house was sold for a handsome profit by the homeowners,who had every right and should have done that, then we were screwed. there are a lot of people who lived in Somerville and this is exactley what happened to them.
Driving up the Prices
I always found it odd that people became angry and hostile at the newcomers when the people with money were only a small part of the changes in the neighborhood.
For renters, the rise in rents everywhere in the region pushed professionals into places like Davis square. Sure, they displaced families, but they themselves might have gone elsewhere if MA wasn't so very obtuse about land use planning and required cities and towns to get with the program and permit the development of adequate number of apartments and the kind of public transportation the region needed to get people from those apartments to their jobs.
The biggest part was the demise of the multigenerational household, which was a national trend.
The second major and ultimately biggest issue was the large families that resulted in houses being sold to settle estates. This happened to our neighbors in Arlington - her mother owned the house, but she had six siblings who wanted a piece of the sale after her mother died. The house was sold, and the earnings were split to settle the estate. The other six didn't think it was fair that our neighbor would just get the house when she had lived there rent-free for thirty years, even if she did care for their mother for much of it.
I had friends who rented and got put out by new owners when multifamily properties were sold to condo developers as a result of settling estates. You didn't have to be related to the owner for this process of splitting assets amongst multiple heirs to get you.
Then there was the end of rent control in Cambridge, where people had been living for twenty years in extremely cheap places despite making six figures for ten or fifteen years. That really pushed up prices but huge in places like Davis Square and Arlington.
Nobody wants to hate their family, or get mad at their parents who sold a house they inherited rather than pass it along, so hating on Barneys was the order of the day. Never mind that there were the larger social trends of people moving out of the cities and the rise of condos and complicated estates and the utter lack of planning or regional sense of needs and everything else. That's too much to think about.
townie in boston
Ok so I think I'm getting it now..... A standard townie is someone who lives in a small town and is small town minded. (Like the townie i was always familiar with.) In the Boston area "townie" means someone who lives in a large city but but acts and thinks like they are in a small town? Is that what you are saying? And apparently there are many of these types of townies around here?
Townie = town/gown
In many college "towns" (including cities), the interaction between the local residents and the students is known as "town/gown relations". Thus, a townie is someone who's -from- the town, as opposed to Those Kids Who Zip Through Here.
The "town" doesn't have to be a "small town"; any local person with local roots is a townie.
Swirly - classic Barney.
Swirly - classic Barney. Come out of the closet and wear it with pride.
Not exactly ...
I spent the first half of my childhood in communities of less than 8,000 people, not suburbs of NY or NJ.
I always thought you needed
I always thought you needed money to be a yuppy.
Explain "townie" in a boston context
Please define "townie" in a boston context.
Very simple. Go to Yelp and
Very simple. Go to Yelp and read some Jamaica Plain reviews. The standard Yelp reviewer considers middle-aged long-time residents who frequent certain bars to be "townies." As opposed to "us," who came here to go to school, eat in ethnic restaurants, and have "Save Darfur" signs on our front lawn.
Think Town and Gown.
Yes of course thats where
Yes of course thats where the word "townie bar came from." Thats what we used to call the bars that the townies hung out at and not the college kids from the nearby campus in that small town I went to college in. But once again that was a very small town in a rural area so its expected. Jamaica Plain is not that. Its part of Boston for gods sake! Once again- how can you be a townie in a big city?? It just doesn't make sense.
You have to realize Boston
You have to realize Boston is a city made up of distinct neighborhoods. (I'm the one who posted with the book recommendations).
Neighborhoods
Yes I realize that most cites do have distinct neighborhoods ie: nyc has chelsea, hell's kitchen, murray hill, upper west side, soho etc... But it doesn't make them them a bunch of seperate little towns full of townies silly. It's still all just one big city. Or L.A has west hollywood, inglewood. santa monica, venice beach, etc...
You get the picture.
Yes,I know what you mean,
Yes,I know what you mean, but that's how it's used in the Boston area. Definately used to describe people originally from Charlestown most often. But I've also heard people from Waltham, Norwood, and other towns referred to as Townies.
It's just a figure of speech, you can't get too literal or technical about it.
Townies in a Boston Context
Townies, in the negative context, are people who grew up and stay in that town that they call their home. The connotation is negative because it infers they are 'small' minded people, and have no desire to move out of the general 'town' they grew up in. In Boston this tends to be the different neighborhoods.
Townie has a middle class connotation to it as well. However, a middle class person moving to Slumerville will never be considering a townie in the strictest sense of the word, unless they are content to eat at crap pizza joints or whatnot.
Townies can't really exist without a large 'transplanted' or 'temporary' population, such as near a university, or large industry.
That's how I definie it anyways. I'm sure DouchyGirl will have all sorts of liberal artsy soup kitcheny answers. Huzzah for the triple decker. In any other place in the country it would be a slum, in Somerville and Rozzie, its a palace!
Advice From a Native
With all due respect to all of you guys,
Anyone in Greater Boston who would refer to a person who hails from anywhere but Charlestown, Massachusetts a "townie" is not a Greater Boston native, and risks getting the $(#$)(%U kicked out of them by a Townie.
I think you might actually be talking about the "Native vs. Newcomer" tension, not "townie vs. yuppie."
You'll never be a Somerville Native because you were born elsewhere (duh). But, do not despair. It is possible to lose your Newcomer status. The key is to be accepted by the Natives as "Good People."
Here is how to be promoted from from Newcomer to Good People:
Live in a neighborhood for at least 10 years.
Own a car in the same crappy price range as your neighbors. Not owning a car or riding a bike will NOT help you to become accepted as "good people." You need a crappy car like the rest of us.
Eat and drink at the same places as the natives while wearing similar clothing to the natives.
Keep your mouth shut about how quaint the working people are.
OR, TO FAST-TRACK:
Have a baby and send the kid to the crappy local schools, go to the crappy local little league games, etc.
Good luck!
I will stay a newcomer
Well a lot of people here are attaching yuppy to newcomer and townie to native.
Ok by your definition of a native or what you call "good people" I want absolutely nothing to do with. Thanks but I'll stay a newcomer forever if I have to. Why would I want to look like everyone else? I speak my mind about how I feel whatever it is I don't shut my mouth. I admit I do have a crappy car but thats about it and I don't intend on having it forever. lol Maybe I will jus ride my bike and take the red line or maybe I'll have a phat ride. Who knows but I won't be a native or townie by your definition.
Ok I'm hoping you were kidding..
awesome
This is exactly right. Nicely explained.
Yay!
Thanks, anon! I don't know why my humble suggestion made being considered "good people" sound so awful, though. (sigh).
I don't see it
I don't really see it all that much, to be honest.
Somerville, especially the areas around Davis Sq, Teele Sq, Union Sq, and Ball Sq, has been undergoing a lot of gentrification, and that's bound to produce some friction. It also shows up in politics - there are divisions between more-traditional Democratic party people (many of them growing up in the area, in some cases with family roots in Somerville for generations) and a more-progressive wing (many of them living in the area for quite some time, but not always quite as long).
Mostly, though, I think that kind of name-calling only appears when there's some other conflict - it doesn't seem to be the actual source of any real problems.
gentrification
I didn't say I thought it was a problem but its just words I've heard so much around here like "gentrification" and yes I know what that means its happening all over America not just here but surely there is a a lot of it here.
It's not especially real, and massively overhyped
mostly as a way for the two local newspapers to differentiate themselves. Ignore it.
yuppy
If you are moving there from Brighton because Somerville is "artsy, diverse, and laid back", then it is safe to say you are on the yuppie side of the fence.
but I am not a yuppy
God I am not a yuppy! I have always despised yuppies. If you saw me you would think I am the furthest thing from a yuppy! I don't get it!
Not clear here...
You're moving to Davis to get _away_ from meathead jocks and college kids? Have you actually been to Davis?
But seriously, there are hardly any townies-- universally defined as adults who live in the same community/neighborhood in which they were born, no matter the size of the community-- in Davis any more. Close to zero. What you have are people who always add the phrase "it's so close to Cambridge" when they describe where they live, and a large group of "hybrids," as aptly described by ShadyMilkman. Some of these are yuppies in terms of their age and income; plenty of others are bridge-and-tunnel types who don't quite fit the yuppie (too old, and/or not rich enough) but who are most definitely not yuppies.
Rest assured that most of the townies won't dig you, though. I lived over there for a couple of years in the 90's and was always struck by the fact that so many of the longtimers harbored such obvious hatred for newcomers. Not all of them, but a lot, and certainly more than in God's Country. Maybe you'll dig it, I don't know, and it's certainly different from Brighton, but once you're there for a while you might find out that "Davis Sq. is the Paris of the 90's" was meant, by most people, as an ironic statement.
bridge-and-tunnel
Sounds like I'm a bridge-and-tunnel type whatever the hell that means LOL! Does that mean you commute into the city for work but you live right next to the city? and what the hell does the "Paris of the 90's mean"? Wow I'm learning so many new terms here.
Paris of the 90s
was a not-especially-serious reference to the large numbers of writers and artists who had settled in the greater Davis Square area, at the same time as several locally-owned coffee places opened.
Yeah basically?
Yeah basically? Bridge-and-tunnel was originally a New York City term for people who live outside of Manhattan (mainly the other boroughs and New Jersey, I guess) and travel in, because bridges and tunnels are the only way a person can get into Manhattan island.
I think I've come to a
I think I've come to a conclusion, whether you were being sarcastic or not you make fun of the college kids and "jocks" lol does that even exist past high school? I have yet to see that in college, they are usually just called douches.
And then you state you are moving to an area to be cool. So you aren't a yuppie, unless you shop at Barney's and eat at Strega's. You aren't a townie, since you cant say that youve lived in "X city" for 40 years and a million other family members in the area.
So you must just be a geek/hipster. it sucks, id rather be a yuppie, atleast they get hot wives and drive nice cars.
geek/hipster
Nope I'm definitely not a geek/hipster. Funny I was trying to understand exactly what a hipster was last week and I do not fit into that category either. We could start a whole new blog on what we think a hipster is. Why do we have to be put in a certain category anyway?
Definition of hipster
One who drinks PBR as a fashion statement. Usually bearded, and way too into Joss Whedon movies.
PBR??
I drink PBR because its cheap and pretty good beer. I usually drink bud light though that's my fav. Why someone would drink that as a fashion statement is beyond me. I dont have a beard although I could grow one in like 3 days if i wanted to, and I have no idea who Joss Whendon is.
OK I guess I'm not a hipster.
PBR == no taste. Bud Light is not beer
Around my part of Somerville I think you'll more likely find people drinking Guinness or Harpoon or sometimes Sam.
Wander into Redbones on Chester Street, or Downtown Wine & Spirits on Elm, and you'll be confronted by a dizzying array of obscure beers you've never heard of.
I know I've heard that
I know I've heard that before and have been made fun of it for it many times but i dont give a crap i never claimed to be a beer snob. I just like good, light beer that I can catch a buzz on without feeling bloated and like I got ripped off. I never like the heavy, hoppy stuff with a bitter aftertaste. That's just what I prefer to each his own.
Bud Light
The official beer of Somerville !!
perfect i will fit right
perfect i will fit right in....
cool
and i didn't say I was moving to an area to be cool but rather that is cool. I am already cool.
Ah BU student then
Ah BU student then
no
Ha! A BU student? I'm in my early 30's so if I was a BU student I'd think I'd have some issues lol
hate to break it to you...
But it's still pretty much Slummerville. Yes, Davis is nice (and is why anyone who lives in Somerville says "I'm close to Davis!" when they are really 20 blocks away), but the rest of Somerville is still pretty much the same as it has been for decades.
One change
The Portuguese mom and pop stores now have green flags on them, along with a new coat of paint or two.
mom & pop
Oh yeah that's a another reason I like the "ville" there are lots of independent mom & pop stores. So much better than crappy chains.
apropos of nothing Somerville...
rageagainst, read Common Ground by J. Anthony Lukas, and/or All Souls by Michael Patrick Mac Donald, if you want a little local history and perspective on "townie."
Aside from that, basically a townie is someone who's "from" wherever you happen to be talking about and still lives there, city, small town, doesn't matter.
I disagree
Thanks for the good read suggestion. I'll check it out. However I must correct you. I disagree with your definition of "Townie" though. So what you are saying is a townie is someone who is just originally from that given city or town. That means that someone who is originally form NYC is therefore a 'townie" ? I'm sorry I have never heard anyone call themselves or be called a "townie" in NYC or any other city for that matter. I think they would actually be offended by that and laugh at you.
townie definition
In Boston and the Greater Boston area, I mean.
You're confusing yourself
You started this thread because you don't understand what Bostonians mean by "townie". And although several people have explained it to you several times, you still "disagree" with them on its meaning.
If you would accept that "townie" means whatever the person saying it wants it to mean, you might better understand what that person is saying.
Townie is a term commonly
Townie is a term commonly used in university towns to refer to residents not affiliated with the university. Tufts is a University or Townie is also a term for someone who has not left the town in which they were born and raised.
And it's not yuppies. It's hipster doofuses that are invading the city(my city for my whole life) and ruining it. They aren't even Barneys. They are a lower lifeform. At least the barneys are genuinely clueless. The HDs are doing it on purpose because they feel there is something ironic about adults playing kickball. They need to shave the beards, toss out the Che tshirts and stop using vintage lunchboxes as breifcases and grow up.
yes!
I was going to suggest the exact same thing to him.
And to add to the confusion, everybody keep in mind that in Somerville "townie" may specifically refer to someone from Charlestown. That is the even more local meaning than the town/gown-yuppie definition kicked around above.
Your post
Couldn't be more wrong. I guess getting 300K for a 2 bedroom condo on the other side of the city from Davis is the way it has always been ? Union Sq is the same as it was 20 years ago ? The only thing the same is the Red House.
I also made the same move
I also made the same move you are contemplating, Brighton to Somerville. I will say that the quality of life is better in Somerville. Not just in Davis Sq, but really any neighborhood north or west of Union Sq.
There are still a lot of sports obsessed 20 somethings here (I'm one of them), but definitely less trust fund drones than in Brighton. It's more "real world" I guess.
Yes quality of life I
Yes quality of life I totally forgot to mention that in my original post. Of course another reason I am moving out of brighton to somerville. Yes trust fund drones exactly!
Don't get me wrong I love sports too I have all my life and love the NFL and I can get obsessed with fantasy football. I just was never that into baseball and that's huge around here. I could care less about the red sox and everyone will hate me for it. God forbid if I was a yankee fan! Its just in your face everywhere you go. I actually know a lot about sports and have played sports most of my life. Its just that sports isn't ALL what my life is about. It doesn't rule it like a lot of people I've met around here. I'm into to a lot of things and sports is just one of them. I've just run into a lot of people around here that only watch and talk about sports. that's what I meant.
This might explain some
This might explain some things...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEVdca9U9LM
I think the whole
I think the whole yuppie/townie thing is how gentrification gets presented to the public. Somerville is on its way up, but not all of its residents are and that causes some social unrest. The most pressing issue, I think, is real estate. People (or yuppies) come in and upgrade houses, raising property values (and also depressing the worst properties) which causes all sorts of displacement among renters and low(er) income familes which may have been here for decades. If you are here to be part of the community, I don't think these issues will cause you much trouble.
Thanks
Thanks for all your comments on this blog I really appreciate it. I'm learning a lot.
Is Davis square really part
Is Davis square really part of Somerville? I mean, there aren't any gays, huspanics or large amounts of garbage, so isn't it more of a college / post college enclave?
Any place that considera a chain link fence as outdoor decor is not up and coming. I'm sure if Ron Neuman saw you coming, he'd run to a coffee shop and blog about it.
hmmm
Spoken like someone who doesn't have any idea what they are talking about.
Davis Sq is the lesbian capital of greater boston.
well
Like somebody else posted above, have you actually been to Davis? You say you want to live in an "artsy, diverse, and laid back" place. It might be laid back, but I don't know about the first two. Davis feels like Brookline to me, minus Brookline Booksmith. Lots of kids and families, stroller parades, a little suburban frankly (not that there's anything wrong with that). Plus you used the word artsy, which has its own set of connotations.
Central Sq
Honestly I originally was looking in cambridge but it was hard finding a nice place there at a reasonable price plus I have a car right now which is much tougher to have in cambridge. So people were telling me about davis sq so i checked it out and I really liked. Plus its on the redline so its only 2 stops from central sq so I can be there in like 5 min and not have to drive through into cambridge and find parking which is a nightmare. Its like you get the best of both worlds. Plus I like the way somerville runs there city v.s. cambridge. Someone actually told me that Davis is basically cambridge not somerville. Getting to Cambridge is a major pain from the brighton/allston area whether you drive or take the T. It's almost as if the area was built to keep the two areas seperated.
It's almost as if the area
The Boston area has a spoke and wheel mass transit system. By that I mean its generally easier to get from anywhere to Downtown Boston then to the cities and towns right next door. Due to this you find that many people, especially those that work outside the city, end up driving/walking/taking the local bus to do most of their errands. College students, and young professionals tend to do the opposite, they go into the city and other places that are considered cool. This plays back to your earlier comment about someone not knowing where South Station is, they do not care because they do not take the train or subway.
The MBTA has a tentative plan to cross connect outside of the Downtown Boston area, it is called the Urban Ring, but it has been slow moving and who knows what will come of it in this current economic climate.
BTW Im a long term local in an immediate Boston suburb but never really considered myself a "townie". On the other hand we never had much of a college population here so I guess it never came up.
spoke and wheel
Ahhh yes you are absolutely correct. Funny how you would never know that about the transit system here until you live here for a while. I wonder what they were thinking when they built the system. Hmmm everyone will need to get downtown and back but will never need to get anywhere else. lol
Yeah I think I heard about the MBTA ring plan but the way transit projects go around here we will all be long dead before that's done
my take on townies
I think you can have townies anywhere and they aren't always "bad" like some people want to think. My take is that there are 2 types of townies.
One type is the guy who never left his parents house after getting out of high school, maybe went to North Adams St. for a year, and then finds himself living with his parents again until he is age 30-40. Living with your parents isn't necessarily bad, but the townie doesn't really have any long term carrer goals. He is satisfied with working at the local sub shop, and having a few bud bottles at the local bar for lunch and then going back to work. The townie isn't a bad person, but he has a routine, and likes to stick to that routine. He takes care of his parents landscaping, shovels the snow, is nice to his mom, and like to attend every wake and funeral of other townie relatives. Granted, the Brighton Townie that has his lunchtime beer at Joey's is going to be a little rougher than the Newton Townie that has his lunchtime beer at Dunn's. But they are one in the same. Good people for the most part, but they dont want outsiders buying their bars, sub shops or department stores and changing them either.
The other type of townie is simply the guy who went away for college and first job, and then came back to live near his family in the town he loves. He has money can afford a nice single family house at a young age, knows everyone in town, still likes to have the bud bottle at the local bar, sends his kids to the same public schools he went to, and has a general pride for the town he grew up in.
Now of course both types of townies have special bonds with each other. They both went to the same public schools, and most times remain friends as they get older.
Im going to say there are 2 major factors in being a townie. One is living in the town you grew up in and went to school in, and the other is being able to go to 10 places in that town and run into an x number of people you know at those locations including parents, relatives and friends of those people you know.
Its not a science, but townieology is an interesting subject to be sure.
townieology
Townieology I like that. lol Maybe they will offer the course at one of the many local universities..
I have to say that where I am from if you are that first type of townie I believe they called you a loser.
well...
The "loser townie" wont help his parents. He lets his 75 year old dad shovel the snow while he sleeps in, and doesn't he doesn't pay any rent. The "loser townie" wont go to any funerals, and he doesn't love the town he grew up in. He simply lives there becasue his parents never threw him out and he has not choice. The loser townie also usually has a criminal record that includes bar fights, minor domestic disputes, and a few other disorderly offenses.
I didn't want to include the "loser townie" in that first category I mentioned. So I guess there are 3 types of townies.
Thats true, the other townie
Thats true, the other townie type is someone who will help fix up your car and will tell you that some weird guy was in your yard yesterday. I know plenty of guys who work at the local sub shop etc who are really cool people. Those of us who got an education and came back really do not appreciate people calling our friends without degrees losers unless they are real jerks.
Right
And I didn't want to imply that the "general townie" (as opposed to the "loser townie" or "educated townie") is someone that always drinks during lunch or lives with their parents.
They aren't rich though, so they usually do live with their parents or rent a cheap apartment. The general townie also might have other general townie roomates to split the rent at 30+ years old.
I also didn't want to imply that the "general townie" doesn't work hard. They actually do. Typical "general townie" jobs might include the following: policeman, fireman, landscaper, DPW worker, contractor, retail worker, bar worker (bartender, bouncer, waiter), sub/pizza shop worker, maintence worker, painter just to name a few.
But like you said Shady, the "general townie" is usually the nicest type of Bostonian. He will help you fix your car, or even lend you his car if you need it. He will lend you that $1,000 you might need, or give you that ride to the airport at 5am.
My comment was aimed at
My comment was aimed at Rage, I agreed with your other points... you are right about the general townies, those are the guys I depend on to get the job done.
I would move to say that while police officers and fire fighters act like general townies they are in the yuppie salary levels and unless we are talking Boston (residency required) many tend to live in higher end communities these days. Many officers make in the 100,000 range which would blow over the other general townies who are lucky to make 50,000 years of working in the same place and becoming a manager with many settling for 28,000 for life.
Yea I didn't mean the top 25%
of officers that you see in the top salaries of towns, I meant the bottom 25% who dont have college degrees and dont do overtime and details (providing more overtime and details for the top 25%!). Those guys make the minimum 40-60K and like to spend 20K of that on beer, casinos and softball keggers.
And 100K isn't buying you a house today in the rich towns either. In 1980 a cop could buy a house in Wellesley, Newton, Brookline or Dover on cop salaries back then. Cops in those towns today cannot buy a house even if they made 150K-200K.
Another type of townie
I would call this person a "myopic townie". These are the people that insist on making every issue into an us versus them issue, even when the consequences of this behavior are extremely negative. The myopic townie works and lives in town, does not understand the need for people to ever leave the island, and refuses to understand the overlapping nature of local, regional, and national phenomena. Thus you get statements like "this is only about regional issues and is being shoved down our throats" without any sense that regional issues could possibly affect them, their neighbors, or their children. To these folks, everything outside the island is the enemy, and life is a perpetual football rivalry.
I've seen a fair bit of this with the green line extension into Medford - the idea that the current generation will not be able to pass along their houses to the next generation if that next generation is unable to access employment adequate to support that house and household is completely lost on them.
This has got to be the greatest Townie discussion ever
This has got to be the greatest and most expansive townie blog in the history of blogs. I don't know why but for some reason its just so damn fascinating.
townies live in a bubble
You are right swirlygrrl. You made some very good points. You could say that some townies live in a bubble. Actually I would say that most townies live in a bubble and that is the typical townie in your most basic form.
Well its their bubble and
Well its their bubble and your in it...
I live here too
It is my region, city, town, state and country and home too. Sorry, but being someplace "first" does not make you more of a citizen or make your vote matter or count more. Nor does your failure to comprehend the existence of a regional economy that can destroy your ability to maintain your bubble make you less wrong for pretending it does not exist.
I pay taxes, I have rights as a citizen and my vote counts just the same whether I was born here or elsewhere. Willfully self-isolating fools don't get to call all the shots because they wail "but I own this town" and stomp their feet and say "lalalalalala can't hear you". They can stomp and whine, but they don't get to have special rights based on their being given property by their parents and their self-destructive xenophobia.
unless you live in a historic district bubble....
then you have some special rights.
well said swirlygrrl
That's right. It should just help you know where the good places to eat are nearby and the fastest way to get someplace and not get lost. I allows you to be helpful to the newcomers who don't know these things yet.
Amen
ShadyMilkMan - AMEN.
Add me to the list of people
Add me to the list of people who think the division is overrated. And I disagree that "locals" won't accept someone who rides a bike or drives a different car. People in Somerville will like people who don't act like they are better than them. That's about it. So if you ride a bike, don't lecture people for driving. If you have a nice place, don't make comments about other houses that might be seen as putting them down. If you are accepting, people around here will mostly accept you. And treat the local culture with respect even if you don't practice all aspects of it.
I am not at all a native Somervillian but I have made it my home over the last 10+ years and have friends who are from here as well as from elsewhere. The whole thing only gets legs because there are a few extremes on both sides. They can suck eggs.
Oh, and as for the comment about the crappy local schools, my son is in the local schools and they are fine. Its not Wellesley but it sure isn't crappy. And the diversity is a big plus.