Hey, there! Log in / Register

Convicted drug dealer admits he shot Northeastern student to death in beef she had nothing to do with

Convicted coke dealer Cornell Smith, 33, pleaded guilty today to shooting Rebecca Payne to death in her Mission Hill apartment in 2008, the Suffolk County District Attorney's office reports.

Suffolk Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Locke sentenced Smith to 18 to 20 years in state prison for voluntary manslaughter - a sentence that will run concurrently with the 12-18-year federal drug sentence he is already serving for a Dorchester drug arrest three months after Payne's murder. Smith was on bail on another drug case when he shot Payne to death.

In court today, Smith admitted to charges that he went to Payne's building to shoot up a rival drug dealer he thought had ratted him out, but broke into the wrong apartment, mistook Payne for her and shot her repeatedly instead.

Smith had originally been indicted on a charge of first-degree murder; prosecutors agreed to the lesser charge in a plea bargain in part because of the unrelated death of a key witness last May. The investigation into Payne's death was initially hampered when none of her neighbors called 911 even after hearing the shooting, prosecutors say.

Prosecutors say they got a break last year in reviewing filings in the federal drug case against Smith:

Among those filings were letters that Smith had sent to the federal court in which he appeared to take responsibility for Payne’s homicide. Bradley relayed his findings the the homicide trial team.

In addition to “apologizing to the Paynes and the Balba family” in those letters, Smith wrote of his physical confrontation with the rival female drug dealer, “which was leading to the unfortunate passing of Rebecca Payne at the hands of I, Cornell Alan Smith, Sr.”

“The Payne family has spent seven years waiting, wondering if they would find justice for their daughter,” DA Dan Conley said in a statement. “Her killer’s unequivocal admission of guilt gives them a sense of finality and I hope this 20-year prison sentence provides some small measure of accountability in the face of their loss.”

Neighborhoods: 
Topics: 
Free tagging: 


Ad:


Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!

Comments

Concurrently?

What's the magic formula one needs to brew to be able to get away with a crime in this manner? Oh, I suppose you just have to say "my bad" in court.

up
Voting closed 0

The DA could have gone to trial without their witness and the guy could have been found not guilty. How would you feel then?

I'd love to see how 18 years in prison after a guilty plea is "getting away with a crime"?

up
Voting closed 0

Most folks would have stumble way out their fucking way to ever be in consideration for a single 18 year gig in prison. This marvel managed to do it twice for half the price. I consider that getting away with a crime.

The DA could gird his loins, prosecute this scumbag for what he had done, and accept a potential acquittal. If the DA lost, this guy would be doing pretty much the same amount of time (outside of parole nuances). The criminal gets a lame punishment for a MURDER, and the DA puts another notch in his belt in this case. We're all good, amirite?

up
Voting closed 0

If they went to trial and he won, he's serving the same sentence that this plea resulted in. If he lost, he could be off the street forever. That's how he got away with a crime -- no additional penalty for committing it.

They had what amounts to a written confession. I do not understand how this plea bargain made sense to the DA.

up
Voting closed 0

Something like 19 out of 20 cases nowadays are plead out rather than go to trial. The prosecutors are primarily concerned about costs, and assuring wins on their record, than the uncertainty of a trial.

up
Voting closed 0

You try a case with witnesses and evidence. You win when they support the story they tell. So how do you try a case with a dead witness and no evidence? If you have a great idea I'm sure everyone would love to hear it.

There are plenty of cases of innocent guys convicted on weak evidence. Is your recommendation to use evidence that's even weaker because the victim was a pretty girl?

up
Voting closed 0

I missed the other conviction.

Still, what is justice? The killer admitted in court what he did, in the presence of family, and received a sentence.

My question was/is- would it have been better if this went to trail and he got off? If you cannot figure out the difference, I am glad for you, as you've never been in the sitation the Paynes have been in. They've at least got closure.

up
Voting closed 0

So you think an 18 year prison sentence will actually put him behind bars? Liar. You know better.

up
Voting closed 0

Sure, he could get good time credits while behind bars, but feel free to explain who someone sentenced to 216 months behind jail ends up on the street after 48 hours.

Of course, I accept that this sentence is concurrent with the trafficking charge, but now, thanks to you, I look less stupid. Thanks.

up
Voting closed 0

Except in certain special cases, there is no parole for persons convicted in Federal court. Since he doesn't fit those special cases, he's going to be in prison for a long time. The murder should have made it a much longer time. I don't think this guy is going to have one of those epiphanies that turn criminals into model citizens; I think he's going to come out bigger and even meaner, and will continue to be a menace.

up
Voting closed 0

Simple, you take a plea deal. They can offer pretty much anything to get the defendant to plead guilty and save them the effort of a trial.

up
Voting closed 0

How the Hell is a premeditated murder which happens to kill the wrong target manslaughter?

The plea deal and concurrent sentence is a slap in the face to Payne family. Judges and let's give any smuck a deal DAs in this state are all to often a disgrace when it comes to providing adequate justice in sentencing to victims and their families.

up
Voting closed 0

The perp walking since the prosecution's star witness is dead.

Conley holds an elected position. I look forward to seeing "anon (not verified)" on the ballot in 2018.

up
Voting closed 0

Conley holds an elected position.

And that's exactly it. Now Conley can assuredly add this case to his list of victories when he's stumping for reelection, rather than face the possibility of losing this case and having his opponent slam him with it.

up
Voting closed 0

THE PERP WOULDN'T BE WALKING IN THIS CASE BECAUSE THEY ARE ALREADY SERVING A SENTENCE. THE PLEA FOR A CONCURRENT SENTENCE ALLOWED THEM TO GET AWAY WITH A FREE MURDER! Even if the case went to trial and the defense won the jail time is the same as the deal. THAT'S THE FRICKEN DISGRACE!

up
Voting closed 0

This guy would haven't gone around with a gun looking for somebody who "ratted him out." I have friends who do coke and they work and don't cause any trouble.

Give coke dealers storefronts and a nice shirt, not jail time. Except, of course, for this one, let him go to jail.*

*I resolved this year not to talk about death on UH anymore.

up
Voting closed 0

So your friends don't cause any trouble. Except in Mexico where maybe 20,000 men, women and children are murdered often via butchery every year by narco gangs supplying coke to your friends.

But less me guess... those murders are really caused US drug laws and really have nothing to do with drug users.

up
Voting closed 0

But less me guess... those murders are really caused US drug laws and really have nothing to do with drug users.

Well, I can't help but notice that cartels aren't killing people to smuggle avocados into the US.

up
Voting closed 0

I know this thread is old, and I typically can't stand Mr. LaTulippe.. but those people are killed for money, not because everyone in the cartel is high. And if our drug laws didn't create a black market, there would be no profit motive. Thats why Al Capone and his buddies killed hundreds of people over booze, but we don't often see our corner liquor providers and barmen gunning each other down. So yeah, A+ on the guess.

up
Voting closed 0

People on this blog obviously have never been involved in an investigation or prosecution as complicated as this one. While I'm sure the prosecution team wanted more, the state of the evidence is what drives the plea. Having a key witness die shortly before trial makes it far more difficult.

When all is said and done Cornell Smith will have been in jail since the time of this murder for 23 years. Only a portion is running concurrent with the remainder of the drug case.

Is 23 years enough? Clearly not, but at least the family has the answers as to what happened and he is paying a significant price for his crime..

up
Voting closed 0

You're joking...right?

up
Voting closed 0

Nice and classy neighbors

up
Voting closed 0

It's horrible that this whole legal process took seven years. I imagine the cops got their guy within 72 hours. Why does criminal justice take so long?

up
Voting closed 0

I don't have my Globe in front of me, but he was caught almost accidentally due to paperwork involving his drug charge.

up
Voting closed 0

The Cops should go after the rival female drug dealer and the DA should put her away for years.

up
Voting closed 0