Hey, there! Log in / Register

Woman killed by I-93 manhole cover was on way to work as an art teacher in Milton

The Globe reports on Caitlin Clavette, who died this morning when a 200-lb. manhole cover came flying into her car in the O'Neill Tunnel just before the Expressway.

Topics: 


Ad:


Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!

Comments

Awful Tragedy

up
Voting closed 0

go out to Ms. Clavette's family and friends.

Just tragic.

up
Voting closed 0

My condolences and prayers for her family, colleagues, and friends.

But there's also a sad lesson in this tragedy for those charged with keeping watch over our roads, bridges, elevators, escalators, stairwells, utility poles, and everything else we all use and pass by without giving a second thought: people's lives depend on you to do your job right every time.

I do my share of trolling and railing against the way the roads are and are not taken care of around here, and if I may be forgiven taking this young woman's name in vain, this is exactly what I'm bitching about. Every metal plate that's left in the road a day longer than needed, every street that's dug up twice for two weeks instead of once for three-and-a-half, every pothole that's allowed to grow and grow. All of these things can turn into a sad story very quickly, and there is no good, sane, or moral reason to keep letting it happen or to make excuses for those who allow it to happen through lack of leadership and lack of awareness.

Road maintenance should be treated like aircraft maintenance: a top flight job with high standards, high pay, high expectations that those filling it can meet those standards, and a high probability of dismissal for those who can't.

up
Voting closed 0


I do my share of trolling and railing against the way the roads are and are not taken care of around here, and if I may be forgiven taking this young woman's name in vain, this is exactly what I'm bitching about. Every metal plate that's left in the road a day longer than needed, every street that's dug up twice for two weeks instead of once for three-and-a-half, every pothole that's allowed to grow and grow. All of these things can turn into a sad story very quickly, and there is no good, sane, or moral reason to keep letting it happen or to make excuses for those who allow it to happen through lack of leadership and lack of awareness

"trolling" sounds about right.

"...this is exactly what I'm bitching about." No. Until anybody gets a decent idea of what happened and how it happened, you don't know "exactly" anything. There are qualified experts examining the evidence to determine the "exactly what".

As your little rant goes on, do you realize you're complaining about both work that goes on too long and work that goes on too often? Get off the fence! The work has to get done sometime - which inconvenience would you prefer?

Seriously - take a look around this city and region sometime. Especially at night. Talk to some cops (traffic details) and construction workers and engineers sometime. Around here, very few of our road and transit links are practical alternates/parallels to each other. There's not much will or capital to build new links. Most of those links have to be kept fully open to traffic most of the time or things get snarled - so that means night work. Except... there are theatres & restaurants & Fenway & Garden events that don't let out 'til late evening - so a lot of road/track/switch work can't start until 10 or 11 or midnight or 1 AM. AND.. the morning rush starts earlier and earlier, so those crew have to stop no later than 4 AM to be out of the way by 4:30 or 5 AM. With very few exceptions, links (or even individual lanes of links) can't be taken out of service for extended periods. So, those crews have 3, 4, maybe 5 hours to do work piece by piece - then come back the next night.

up
Voting closed 0

The situation you describe is the exact reason that you need to be widening roads and building new ones. That would be a lot of pain now to forestall the thousand cuts and occasional tragedy Boston's present state of infrastructure yields.

Every single one of the people pulling double duty inspecting the drains and manhole covers right now can be top-notch, but it's the previous decades of short-sighted and otherwise bad decision making that will continue to make Boston roads (marginally) less safe than they need to be.

The last time this sort of fatal accident happened was in 04, but in 07 there were also a few instances of metal covers coming off and causing (non fatal) accidents on 128. I remember this because I had just moved up here, and had never heard of such a thing happening anywhere else.

These things aren't happening daily or monthly, or even annually, which makes their actual rate of occurrence hard to pin down beyond anecdotal certainty. And will take decades to be able to tell if a policy or procedural change really helped.

But in lieu of a crystal ball, some things can be inferred from first principles, and the most basic one is that if two "things" happen to a piece of road, each of which has a small chance of causing a fatality in the future, that's twice the probability of a fatality that you'd accumulate from just one "thing".

And these "things" can be obvious like opening the cover to go down it, popping the storm drain to clear it (can't do much about the frequency of those, just need to be more careful), to the non obvious, like sending the salt trucks around with their plows down before any snow piles up (I've seen more than one preventative scraping of bare asphalt on 128 in the hours before a predicted winter event) and the order in which different kinds of work are scheduled.

Sometimes on the scale of decades. When they stopped running trolleys out of Harvard Square, for instance, Belmont just paved over the tracks on the 73 bus route, and after many many seasonal cooling cycles, the tracks just broke up the pavement above them into a pair of ruts the entire length of the road. That little cost saving move to not rip out the tracks the first time around resulted in decades of whole miles of street where safety is lower because drivers look near to avoid immediate obstacles instead of far to see pedestrians,traffic lights, and opposing traffic, AND there's now a bottomless reservoir of small rocks for car tires to kick up and fling wherever. And guess what: the tracks are still rusting down there the whole time, so you still need to take them out at some point. In fact, there's an ongoing round of work on that road that's seen the 73 converted to buses for a few years so that trolleybus wire can be removed to make room for heavy equipment to resurface the road. If the don't rip out the tracks now, they'll need to be just as disruptive again in the future.

up
Voting closed 0

My condolences to her family and friends. It's inexcusable that such a brutality can happen to a person driving on the streets of this city. I hope that a thorough investigation is set in place to determine how this happened and to punish anyone responsible.

up
Voting closed 0

Comparing the Globe's photo with that in the previous thread, the manhole cover blasted completely through the car, entering through the windshield and not only killing Ms Clavette but completely destroying the rear hatch door. That was some serious ballistic force.

up
Voting closed 0

This reminds me of the tunnel tile collapse from a few years ago. This is a tragedy of the highest order. My prayers to the victim and her family. And I second the comment below from Roman - the state of our roads, bridges, and tunnels are a shameful disgrace and embarrassment. It's unthinkable that these kind of freak fatal accidents occur, but unfortunately they do.

up
Voting closed 0

This story really bothers me. I feel terrible for this poor woman and all her family and friends. This is why you should love the ones you love as much as possible because some people can be doing everything right and the most random things can change your world in an instant. This should never happen to anyone ever.

up
Voting closed 0