Hey, there! Log in / Register
Park Square is freed of that Emancipation statue
By adamg on Tue, 12/29/2020 - 3:07pm
WBUR reports workers today removed that Park Square statue that, however, well intentioned it may have been when first cast, is still a statue of a half-naked Black man on his knees in front of a white man. It'll be put in a warehouse somewhere as the city figures out what to do with it - and what to replace it with.
Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!
The Lincoln statue was offensive to some
But not as offensive as the statue of Leif Ericson on Commonwealth ave. The statue of the viking was a gift of the Boston Brahmans whose champion was a white protestant as opposed to a swarthy catholic called Christopher Columbus.
Is that your attempt to make Italians into non-white people of color? Good luck with that.
Oh, BTW Ericson was a Catholic. Just what point were you trying to make?
The Point Is Yes - It Was An Anti-Italian Movement
In order for the Brahmins to make themselves look better to themselves and lay claim to be the real founders of America, not some Italian guy working for Spain, there was a series of historical "evidence" items claiming that the Vikings and not some southern Europeans discovered America.
Great little stories like the Vikings strolled up the Charles and had an encampment at Norumbega. Vikings building a stone tower in Newport, etchings in rocks, etc. to prove that it was true Norseman and not some 28 generation descendent of a Roman farmer who discovered this great White Protestant Nation or so they thought.
Besides Ericson looking at all of the trash in the Muddy River, did you know the Longfellow Bridge has Viking boat motifs to tie into the Norumbega theory?
Were there Vikings in North America? Probably in Newfoundland on a seasonal basis as shown through research at L'Anse Aux Meadow. Big deal - companies set up and close locations all the time. There are a lot of myths out there like St. Brendan sailing in a small boat out of Tralee all the way across the Atlantic. Let's emphasize myth.
As far as your OH BY THE WAY ERICSON WAS A CATHOLIC fit above, so was nearly everyone else technically in Western Europe outside of parts of Spain and the northern extremities of Scandinavia at that time. You know until that Luther guy came along a few years after Columbus.
So, yes to answer you, the local "it was northern Europeans and not southern Europeans discovered America" thing was in full swing at the time to counter the Eye-talian story was an attempt to discredit those decadent "swarthy" people with their good wine, perfect disco records, great food, and nice weather.
Lots of words
None of which supports anon's claims that Columbus was not "white," or that Ericson was a Protestant. Are you the guy who used to write outraged letters to the Globe, wailing about "Catholic bashing" whenever they reported some priest misbehaving? Columbus is a really bad pick for a hero, and that has nothing to do with his being Italian. Was Ericson also a bad hero? Maybe, but you haven't even tried to make that case.
It Took You 5 Lines To Just Say Nyah Nyah Nyah
You have no coherent retort. Go away.
Whiteness, a fluid social construct, has evolved in the US over time. Italians were definitely not white at one point in our sordid history. Look it up.
Not my job
You look it up, and if you find anything that actually supports it, link to it. I have better things to do.
what are we even talking about here?
what does the leif ericsson statue and whiteness as a construct have to do with the removal of the lincoln statue?
“Good luck with that”
It is well known that once upon a time Italian (and Portuguese and Spanish) immigrants where not considered “white enough” for Protestant white society. This idea is extensively talked about in sociology and history classes and is neither new nor controversial.
Brent Staples’s article “How Italians Became White” does a nice job outlining the issue using the backdrop of the lynching of Italian immigrants in 1891 New Orleans.
No one is arguing that Italians are “people of color” today, but it’s silly to deny that white immigrants from Italy (and Ireland) faced the same virulent racist abuse and obstacles that is often faced by today’s immigrants from places like Latin America and Asia.
I think somebody is, and that's what I originally responded to.
1887 is not today
That comment you link to is about a Leif Erickson statue installed in 1887, totally in the time period I talk about in my comment and totally consistent with the statement that no one is claiming that contemporary, 2020 Italian Americans are people of color.
This is what the other posters were talking about
Not how Italians are viewed today nor the actual religion of Ericksson.
I personally have no opinion on the statue itself.
Then why don't you get up off your anonymous ass and start a movement to have it removed?
(it's ok, no need to respond. We all know why)
Since You Live 100 Miles Away
Why don't you get off your ass and mosey on down I-91 and get Columbus Avenue in Springfield changed to Nasmith Boulevard or Maddow Street?